Less than three years after being sold to the owner of Michael’s craft stores, Pat Catan’s will be closing its 35 stores in Ohio, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia.

“After a comprehensive review, we have made the difficult decision to close the Pat Catan’s retail stores,” according to a statement from a spokesperson for the Michael’s Companies.

In February 2016, when Michael’s purchased rival Pat Catan’s, the new owners said they intended to keep the stores open.